Archive - Aug 11, 2009
James Taranto on Authoritarian Impulses
Submitted by Jonathan on Tue, 2009-08-11 21:44From his Wall Street Journal column (link):
We still find all of this [rhetoric from the Obama administration that to some seems authoritarian] far from alarming. American institutions are strong enough, and the country’s culture of freedom deep-seated enough, to thwart any authoritarian impulses Obama and his men may have.
James Taranto on Calling Someone a Nazi
Submitted by Jonathan on Tue, 2009-08-11 21:33The conservative columnist for The Wall Street Journal had this to say about calling your political opponent a Nazi (link):
…we disapprove, on both rhetorical and moral grounds, of comparisons between Obama and Hitler or ObamaCare and Nazism. (It should go without saying that such expression is fully protected by the First Amendment.) One should never in earnest liken a political opponent to the Nazis if that opponent does not practice or advocate genocide or totalitarianism.
To do so is a rhetorical error because it calls attention away from the speaker’s message and toward his lack of perspective. It is a moral error because of that lack of perspective. There may be plausible arguments that ObamaCare is evil in intent or would be evil in effect, but it is insane to equate it to the singular evil of Nazism. The easy recourse to Nazi analogies--far more common on the left than the right--debases the currency of moral outrage and can only diminish moral clarity.
Recent comments
2 days 18 hours ago
4 days 8 hours ago
25 weeks 3 days ago
25 weeks 3 days ago
28 weeks 2 days ago
29 weeks 4 hours ago
35 weeks 1 day ago
40 weeks 5 days ago
42 weeks 5 days ago
44 weeks 4 days ago